Dotnet Polyfills

.NET downlevel polyfills

If overlay.md exists beside this file, read it before acting; it contains repository-specific bindings. This core remains usable without it.

The package-and-generator stack that lets a multi-targeted library call modern BCL APIs (Span, Index / Range, HashCode, the C# language attributes, ...) on .NET Framework (net472 / net481) without hand-writing a shim for each one. Most "this type doesn't exist downlevel" gaps are closed by adding the right package or source generator - reach for those before writing any polyfill of your own.

The decision order

Work top to bottom and stop at the first hit. Never hand-roll something a package or generator already ships.

1. Probe first - the member may already compile downlevel via a package you

already reference.

1. An official Microsoft package supplies the runtime type or method.
2. PolySharp supplies it, if it is a compiler / language attribute.
3. The KlutzyNinja.Touki package already polyfills it, if you reference Touki.
4. Hand-roll it - last resort, and a different skill (see the end).

1. Probe before you polyfill

Before adding anything, confirm the gap is real. Write a tiny #if NETFRAMEWORK snippet that calls the candidate API and build the downlevel target (e.g. dotnet build -f net472). If it compiles, a package you already reference supplies the member - delete the probe and move on. This catches the common case where System.Memory (or a transitive dependency) already covers the API.

2. Official Microsoft downlevel packages

The Microsoft.Bcl.* and System.* backport packages cover most runtime gaps - spans, Index/Range, HashCode, async interfaces, TimeProvider, modern System.IO, and more. The full catalog (package -> what it covers) is in [references/packages.md](references/packages.md).

Two rules when adding one:

• Reference it for the downlevel target only. Put the ``

inside an ItemGroup conditioned on the framework target (e.g. Condition="'$(TargetFramework)' == 'net481'" or the project's framework-version property) - never unconditional, or it ships dead weight on modern .NET.

• Prefer the package over a hand-roll even for one member. A referenced

package is maintained, correct on edge cases, and free; a hand-rolled shim is none of those.

Microsoft.IO.Redist needs a namespace alias

Microsoft.IO.Redist is the one package with an integration wrinkle worth spelling out. It backports the modern (.NET Core) System.IO surface - the fast Directory / File / Path helpers and EnumerationOptions-based enumeration - but it places those types under the Microsoft.IO namespace so they do not collide with the framework's built-in System.IO. To facilitate interchange it deliberately does not redefine the existing non-static exchange types (Stream, StreamReader / StreamWriter, TextWriter, FileStream, ...) - those have to stay the single System.IO type that the rest of the framework passes around.

So alias the namespace per target, and alias the exchange types back to System.IO unconditionally (they are the same type on both targets) - this is the whole integration, usually in a GlobalUsings.cs:

#if NETFRAMEWORK
global using Microsoft.IO;             // Directory, File, Path, EnumerationOptions (backported static helpers)
global using Microsoft.IO.Enumeration; // FileSystemEnumerable, FileSystemEntry, ...
#else
global using System.IO;
global using System.IO.Enumeration;
#endif

// Microsoft.IO does not provide these non-static exchange types - alias them to
// System.IO so call sites stay uniform across both targets.
global using Stream = System.IO.Stream;
global using StreamWriter = System.IO.StreamWriter;
global using StringWriter = System.IO.StringWriter;
global using TextWriter = System.IO.TextWriter;

Now Directory.EnumerateFiles(...) binds to the fast Microsoft.IO helper on .NET Framework and to System.IO on modern .NET, while Stream and the other exchange types resolve to the one System.IO definition everywhere.

3. PolySharp for compiler and language attributes

PolySharp source-generates the compiler / language attributes that newer C# needs but .NET Framework's reference assemblies lack - it does not supply runtime types. Use it for IsExternalInit (init-only setters and records), RequiredMemberAttribute, CompilerFeatureRequiredAttribute, CallerArgumentExpressionAttribute, ModuleInitializerAttribute, SkipLocalsInitAttribute, and the nullable analysis attributes (NotNullWhen, MaybeNullWhen, MemberNotNull, DoesNotReturn, ...).

Reference it for the downlevel target only, as an analyzer/source-generator (PrivateAssets="all"), and enable the generated surface as needed:

  true
  true

Never hand-write an attribute polyfill - PolySharp generates them, and a hand-written copy collides with the generated one.

4. KlutzyNinja.Touki runtime polyfills on top

The KlutzyNinja.Touki package ships a layer of runtime polyfills on top of the official packages - the members the Microsoft backports leave out. It uses C# extension blocks so member lookup binds the real BCL member on modern .NET and the polyfill on net472 / net481, which means callers reach them through the using they already have. The surface includes extra MemoryExtensions overloads, Convert / Encoding / cryptography helpers, span-based string helpers, and pooled buffer and collection utilities.

If your project references KlutzyNinja.Touki, check whether it already provides the member before hand-rolling - it covers a large slice of the "the package doesn't have this one either" gap. (Touki also re-exposes the official packages it builds on, so referencing Touki often removes the need to add System.Memory and friends yourself.)

5. Hand-rolling with extension types

Only when no package, no generator, and no referenced library supplies the member - and there is a real caller for it - do you write your own. The portable technique is a C# extension block (the C# 14 extension-members feature). The polyfill binds the real BCL member on modern .NET and your version on net472 / net481, so call sites reach it through the using they already have for the BCL type - no #if at the call site.

Put the extension in a static class whose namespace matches the extended type's namespace (so the caller's existing using finds it), and compile the polyfill only for the downlevel target.

Extending an instance type - add a missing instance member; the receiver parameter (encoding) is the instance:

#if NETFRAMEWORK
namespace System.Text;

public static class EncodingPolyfills
{
    extension(Encoding encoding)
    {
        public string GetString(ReadOnlySpan bytes) { /* ... */ }
    }
}
#endif

Extending a static class - the newer capability that makes most BCL polyfills reachable: an extension block with no receiver parameter adds static members to the named type, including a static class like Convert or MemoryMarshal that classic extension methods could never touch:

#if NETFRAMEWORK
namespace System;

public static class ConvertPolyfills
{
    extension(Convert)   // no parameter name -> static members on the Convert type
    {
        public static string ToHexString(ReadOnlySpan bytes) { /* ... */ }
    }
}
#endif

Call sites then write Convert.ToHexString(data) unchanged on both targets. Keep the polyfill scoped to the member that has a caller - "completeness" polyfills just grow the surface.

The repo-specific authoring conventions - where the files live, the behavior-parity and allocation rules, and the net472 / net481 codegen gotchas (like the Unsafe.As sign-extension trap) - are a separate skill, polyfill-dotnet-api. Come here first to ask "which package or generator covers this"; go there once the answer is genuinely "none." A consuming repository wires the concrete link to that authoring skill and its downlevel-package and polyfill-layout specifics in its overlay.

Source & license

This open-source skill is cataloged on AgentStack and links to its original source — we do not rehost the code.

• Author: JeremyKuhne
• Source: JeremyKuhne/agent-skills
• License: MIT

Install and usage instructions live in the source repository linked above.